Compare Progressive vs Other Insurance Providers
Shopping for insurance? See how Progressive stacks up against GEICO, State Farm, The General, and Farmers. We compare rates, discounts, claims service, and digital tools so you can pick the carrier that fits your needs and budget.
From our own experience running live quotes: Progressive often delivers the best price for drivers who value quick online service and easy bundling. GEICO feels simpler if you want a no-fuss quote. State Farm stands out for those who want personal agent support, while The General is great for high-risk drivers who need fast approval. It’s smart to try each carrier’s quote tool—adjusting coverage options live will show you in real time how much you can save by switching or bundling. Sometimes, just moving one deductible slider or adding a discount makes a surprising difference.
Get Real-Time Quotes by ZIP Code
Enter your ZIP code to compare live rates from Progressive and leading competitors—adjusted for local risks, claims history, and weather. This side-by-side approach makes it easy to spot savings on the coverage you want.
Auto Insurance Quote
Home Insurance Quote
Progressive vs Major Insurers: Key Differences
- Progressive vs GEICO: Progressive’s Snapshot® usage-based program rewards safe drivers and their online tools make bundling easy. GEICO wins for no-fuss pricing and loyalty discounts. If you want to maximize digital savings or drive fewer miles, Progressive may edge out GEICO on price.
- Progressive vs State Farm: State Farm is perfect for those who want local agent support, while Progressive excels with fully digital claims, easy policy adjustments, and instant online service—great for tech-savvy or on-the-go customers.
- Progressive vs The General: The General is a go-to for high-risk and SR-22 drivers, but Progressive offers competitive rates and broader options—even if you’re switching from a high-risk status.
- Progressive vs Farmers: Farmers provides deep local expertise and custom endorsements. Progressive stands out for smart mobile apps and real-time discounts, ideal if you like to manage your insurance by phone.
Which Carrier Fits Your Needs?
If you value fast, digital service and want to see the impact of each discount, Progressive’s quote builder shows all savings live—including safe driver, multi-policy, paperless, and more. But if you prefer a personal touch, State Farm or Farmers’ agent networks may be a better fit.
For high-risk auto or SR-22 needs, The General is a strong choice, while GEICO keeps it simple for average drivers. We recommend running quotes from at least two companies—your perfect match may surprise you.
Tips for Smarter Comparisons
- Use the ZIP code form to compare multiple companies at once.
- Check bundling options—auto & home bundles can save 20–25% with most carriers.
- For usage-based discounts, consider Progressive’s Snapshot® or GEICO’s DriveEasy.
- Always review claims ratings and digital tools—fast claims and good apps save hassle.
Next Steps & Resources
After comparing, visit our auto & home bundling guide to maximize discounts. For high-risk homes, explore specialty options. Need a walkthrough? Follow our step-by-step Progressive quote guide for insider tips on getting the best deal.
FAQ – Comparing Progressive and Other Insurers
Which carrier has the fastest claims process?
Progressive’s digital claims can be filed via app in minutes. GEICO and Farmers also offer strong mobile tools, while State Farm is best for agent-based support.
Who offers the best bundling discount?
Progressive can save you up to 25% when you bundle auto and home, with State Farm and GEICO around 20%. Check ZIP-specific offers for details.
Is usage-based pricing worth it?
If you drive under 10,000 miles/year and avoid hard braking, usage-based programs like Snapshot® can save 10–30% based on your habits.